Current Pastor
Fr. James Owusu-Yeboah, SMA December 2021 - present
Visiting Pastors
| Fr. Wendelin Revis | December 1873 – March 1877 |
| Fr. Francis N. Schreiber | March 1877 – October 1878 |
| Fr. Francis Recouvreur | November 1878 – June 1881 |
| Fr. Wendelin Revis | December 1873 – March 1877 |
| Fr. Francis N. Schreiber | March 1877 – October 1878 |
Fr. Francis Recouvreur November 1878 – June 1881
Fr. Patrick McGrath July 1881 – April 1882
Fr. Henry Polvdore Delbaer July 1882 – August 1884
Fr. Thomas J, O’Callaghan July 1884 – July 1887
Fr. B.H. Corley July 1887 – April 1889
Fr. P.A. Conaty June 1889 – February 1891
Fr. Michael Angelo Dooling February 1891 – 1895
Resident Pastors:
Fr. Michael Angelo Dooling 1895 – November 1906
Fr. Francis Joseph Kelly November 1906 – April 1907
Fr. John W. Cummings April 1907 – March 1913
Fr. Edward C. Hearn March 1913 – September 1914
Fr. Stephen N. Moore September 1914 – July 1924
Fr. Edmund M. Hayden July 1924 – August 1928
Fr. Peter E. Lebon* August 1928 – April 1934
Fr. Ernest Blough April 1934 – June 1934
Fr. Andrew A. Timmons June 1934 – August 1940
Fr. Thomas Kelly August 1940 – June 1955
Fr. Stephen Kassovic June 1955 – June 1967
Fr. John J. O’Toolle June 1967 – June 1975
Fr. Robert Creager June 1975 – June 1983
Fr. Duane LeClerq June 1983 – June 1989
Fr. Robert Hoffman June 1989 – June 2000
Fr. Gordon J. Pillon June 2000 – June 2003
Fr. Donald Roszkowski June 2003 – June 2006
Fr. James Henning June 2007 - November 2021
Fr. James Owusu-Yeboah, SMA December 2021 - present
* - died while Pastor